Rogaine vs. Generic Minoxidil
When it comes to hair loss treatment, Rogaine is a name that everyone knows. However, the Rogaine is simply a brand of Minoxidil, and the generic versions can be just as effective in addition to being quite a bit less expensive.
In this article, we’re going to discuss the differences between Rogaine and generic minoxidil. We’ll discuss side effects and considerations, as well as where you can find and purchase different generic brands.
In addition, I’ll share a two-step process you can use to stop your hair loss and possibly even regrow your hair.
Rogaine (Minoxidil) To Treat Hair Loss
To understand how Rogaine differs from its various generics, it’s important to first understand its history and how it works.
Development & Use
Minoxidil is a drug that was originally developed in the late 1950s by Pfizer to treat ulcers. While trials ultimately found that the drug fail to cure ulcers, it did prove to be an powerful vasodilator.
In the 1960s and 70s, it was then developed as a treatment for high blood pressure (hypertension) (1). It was marketed under the name Loniten, and it was prescribed orally as tablets starting in 1979.
Another unexpected use of the drug – discovered during initial trials – was its effectiveness in the treatment of hair loss.
In fact, the drug was so widely known for its hair growth abilities, that doctors were prescribing it off-label to treat their patients who suffered from Male-Pattern Baldness (MPB).
In 1988, the product was FDA approved for use as a hair growth treatment (under the brand name of Rogaine), and in 1991 a solution was approved for women.
Finally, on February 12, 1996, the FDA approved both the over-the-counter sale of the drug and the production of generic formulations of minoxidil. Pfizer replied to that by lowering prices to half the price of the prescription drug and by releasing a prescription 5% formula of Rogaine in 1997.
How Does It Work?
While there’s still a bit of debate surrounding minoxidil’s exact mechanism of action, it’s believed that its vasodilating effects are the most likely cause of its positive effects (2). Theoretically, by widening blood vessels and opening potassium channels, it allows more oxygen, blood, and nutrients to the follicles. This may cause follicles in the telogen phase to shed, which are then replaced by thicker hairs in a new anagen phase. This comes with the following effects:
• If hair follicles have shrunk, they grow larger.
• Blood flow to the hair follicles increases.
• It increases the rate at which hair follicles move between growth phases, encouraging hair to grow faster.
• Each follicle’s growth phase also lasts longer, making them more efficient.
Minoxidil allows the hair follicles to move through the growth phases similar to those who do not have male-pattern baldness. The main difference being that those who use Minoxidil appear to spend less time in the telogen phase. As a result, their hair follicles are more active, so hair grows thicker and longer.
What Type of Hair Loss Does it Treat?
Minoxidil is only appropriate for hereditary hair loss. If you suffer from a condition such as psoriasis or alopecia areata, you should ask a medical professional for advice before applying it to your scalp. Doing so is necessary, as the solution’s ingredients may interact with other drugs you’re taking. Also, if you have any open sores, it will aggravate them.
In individuals with Male Pattern Baldness (medically referred to as Androgenetic Alopecia (AGA)), a sensitivity to DHT causes inflammation of the hair follicles.
DHT is produced from the interaction between testosterone (the male sex hormone) and 5-alpha-reductase (an enzyme), and it’s a normal process that occurs in all men.
Unfortunately, a genetic predisposition to AGA can put you at risk for DHT sensitivity, and this can lead to hair thinning and loss.
As DHT attaches to the androgen receptors at the follicles, the follicles near the front of the scalp and vertex react by inflaming. This leads to a process known as hair miniaturization.
As the follicles become inflamed and irritated as a result of DHT sensitivity, the hair cycle shortens leading to baldness.
As the follicle miniaturizes, the hair follicles spend more time in the telogen phase (phase in which the follicle remains dormant), while spending less time in the catagen (phase where follicles renew themselves) and anagen phases (phase in which hair grows). This eventually leads to thinning and, if not treated, permanent baldness.
During this process, the blood flow to the hair follicle is also restricted. This means the follicles aren’t receiving the amount of oxygen and nutrients they require to thrive, and this further contributes to the miniaturization process.
As a vasodilator, minoxidil widens the blood vessels (3). The necessary constituents can then once again make their way to the follicles (even those inflamed by the presence of DHT), stimulating hair growth to occur, and in many instances causing the rest of your hair to grow in thicker and healthier.
What Happens When You Stop Taking Minoxidil?
Minoxidil is not a cure – but rather a stimulant for hair growth. Thus, Minoxidil needs to be used continually, that is if you stop treatment after your hair has restored, you will lose your regrowth. This makes sense as again the products works as a vasodilator and if you discontinue it’s use, the blood vessels will return to their original state cutting off the additional nourishment to hair follicles that was fueling their growth. It’s worth pointing out that hair loss is progressive, and as a result if you discontinue the products use you are likely to experience additional and continued hair loss over time.
Rogaine vs. Generic Minoxidil: What’s the Difference?
When a product such as Rogaine is patented, the originating company has exclusive rights to its formulation for 20 years (in the US, UK, and Canada). This is the payoff for shouldering the high risk and high costs of developing new drugs, and a way of rewarding companies for their innovations. Once a patent expires, other companies are then able to manufacture non-brand name versions of the very same drug, so-called “generics.”
This is great for consumers, as Rogaine no longer has exclusivity on the hair loss treatment market.
Consumers can now purchase generics – the majority of which are cheaper – and make an informed decision as to which one they like best.
Two of the most popular generic brands are Kirkland Signature Minoxidil (Costco) and Equate (Walmart). However, other brands offer their own self branded minoxidil products.
But what’s the difference between the original brand Rogaine and its generics?
The simple answer to the question… not much.
The active ingredient minoxidil is the same within each product.
What you will notice is that each generic brand varies when it comes to inactive ingredients. This can affect the consistency and, therefore, the way in which each product applies.
While the differences between products is negligible, you may find that certain brands work better for your scalp than others.
For example, many users of Kirkland Signature Minoxidil (a Costco generic) find it’s greasier than Rogaine and other minoxidil-containing products. On the other hand, some users find Rogaine to be too drying. Thus if you have oily scalp / skin, Rogaine may be the better option for you, where as if you have dry scalp / skin Kirkland Signature may be a better option.
When it comes down to it, the one you pick will depend entirely on your personal preference and hair type.
How to Apply
Whether you use the name brand Rogaine or a generic brand, the application of each follows the same process (though, it does vary by solution).
To apply the liquid, you use the applicator tool that’s attached to the lid. Simply collect 1 milliliter of the liquid in the tool, and add the drops to the balding areas of your scalp.
Work the liquid in with clean fingertips, and be sure to wash hands thoroughly. Do not shower or apply other products (including mousse, gel, or hairspray) for at least four hours.
The foam is much easier to apply, and it also dries more quickly. Use the foam applicator to put a dollop of foam in your hand. Use your fingers to apply the foam to the balding areas of your scalp.
Rub until the foam absorbs fully. Allow the foam to dry completely before styling.
Side Effects & Considerations
As with any topical hair loss product, there’s always a risk of side effects. The most common associated with minoxidil solutions include local irritation (4). Symptoms of such irritation includes:
For most, symptoms ease as use continues, however, some may be more sensitive to the product than others. If symptoms continue or worsen, it’s best to stop use and speak with a physician.
A more severe reaction can occur with symptoms including hives, rash, difficulty breathing, and swelling of the lips, mouth, tongue, or throat. If you experience a severe reaction, seek medical attention immediately.
In addition to adverse effects, however, there are also a few things to consider before using Rogaine or any other minoxidil products:
- Minoxidil is not a hair loss cure.
- Your hair loss can (and likely will) return once minoxidil use is stopped.
- Minoxidil doesn’t work for everyone.
In addition, it is very common to experience shedding in the first few months of minoxidil use. This is a normal part of the process, as the hair follicles are cycling from telogen to anagen phase much more quickly.
For the majority of users, the excess shedding will subside in a few months’ time. However, some users are so bothered by the “side effect” that use is discontinued.
Availability and Cost
The majority of drug stores, both online and not, have their own brands of Rogaine product available for purchase.
The cost will vary based upon location, solution (liquid or foam) and strength (2% – 5%).
Some of the more popular brands, such as Kirkland and Equate, can be purchased online and are available using the links below.
Rogaine Hair Regrowth Treatment
Kirkland Signature Hair Regrowth Treatment
Equate Hair Regrowth Treatment
A Natural Alternative to Minoxidil Products (2 Steps)
Like most health and appearance related issues, when it comes to hair loss we all want a quick fix. However, treatment options such as minoxidil do not treat the underlying cause of hair loss.
If you want to truly stop your hair loss and perhaps even regrow the hair you’ve lost, you need to take a more holistic approach.
Here are the steps we recommend:
1. Find the Cause
While MPB can be genetic, this doesn’t mean there aren’t other causes contributing to the issue. To find these causes, we recommend the following approach.
Do an Elimination Diet
Certain foods have been found to trigger hair loss (such as those that are acidic and high glycemic), however, you may also have underlying food allergies and/or sensitivities that are causing inflammation throughout your body.
As we’ve discussed, inflammation is a contributing factor to hair loss and thus you would be wise to take steps to remove as many inflammatory foods from your diet as possible.
An elimination diet is a multi-step program that involves cutting out many food groups and then slowly reintroducing them back into your diet. As you introduce the food groups, you keep a journal tracking any symptoms.
Revamp Your Hair Care Routine
Whether you’re suffering from full baldness, or your hair has only begun to thin, you may not be aware that chemicals in popular hair products can further contribute to your hair loss woes.
Not only can shop-bought products – including shampoos, conditioners, and styling cremes – cause damage to your hair, but they can also further hair loss in people with AGA.
That’s not to say you should stop using over-the-counter products altogether. In fact, many may help you to combat hair loss.
But it’s important to know exactly what you’re putting on your scalp and how it may affect hair growth in the long run.
There are more natural formulations, such as Hairguard, that work to cleanse the scalp while also stimulating the follicles. And they can even be combined with more mainstream treatments (including minoxidil and finasteride), or similar alternatives.
There are other steps you can add to your routine, though, that also contribute to a healthy scalp.
For example, a daily ten-minute scalp massage and a weekly microneedling session can increase blood flow to the scalp. This boost of oxygen and nutrients will support stronger hair, and it may even help to combat the effects of many hair loss conditions.
These two simple additions are just one way to revamp your routine with scalp health and hair growth in mind.
2. Treat the Issue
With a better understanding of your hair loss triggers, it’s now time to treat the issue at its source.
The actual treatment route you take will depend on cause.
Alopecia Areata (AA), for example, is an autoimmune hair loss condition that often requires you to work closely with a dermatologist (8). You may be prescribed steroids or anti-inflammatories, but you can also work with your doctor to find a more viable long-term solution (such as diet change).
AGA is similar in that it’s best to work with a dermatologist.
The most common treatment routes are minoxidil and finasteride but, as mentioned, these don’t treat the underlying problem. Instead, you may find it more beneficial to take a look at other triggers (e.g. diet, environment, lifestyle) and alter those.
That doesn’t mean that minoxidil and other mainstream options can’t be part of your treatment plan. But they shouldn’t be the be-all-end-all.
Your Diet and Hair Loss: How Deep Is the Connection?
As mentioned above, food sensitivities can cause inflammation and keep you in the hair loss cycle. However, there are other aspects of your diet that may be causing you more harm than you think.
While the modern day diet has strayed far from our ancestors’, there is one thing we can still do just like them: Eat foods that will heal our bodies.
Unfortunately, the foods that are most convenient and available are those that are highly acidic and, therefore, unhealthy for your naturally alkaline body.
You can do something about this, though! By altering your diet – aligning it better with the diet of your ancestors – you can treat a significant trigger of hair loss.
So, how can you get started?
Small steps will help you to build a firm foundation. With that in mind…
Reduce Your Intake of Unhealthy Fats
Fats are a necessary part of a healthy diet. However, modern foods are full of unhealthy oils, and they offer little in the way of nutrition or benefit.
It is crucial that you reduce your intake of unhealthy fats – such as those found in fried foods, in packaged snacks, and in high-fat cuts of meat.
Instead, you should focus on the consumption of natural foods that contain fats as a major part of their composition. For example, coconut, avocado, nuts (almond, chestnut, cashew), seeds (pumpkin, flax), and fish (especially cold water).
Increase Your Intake of Fiber
The health of your gut plays a key role in the health of your body. As such, it’s important to increase your fiber intake to clean out your intestines and keep your sugar levels even (9).
High-fiber foods are also more filling, and this can help you to cut back on junk foods.
As the follicles become inflamed and irritated as a result of DHT sensitivity, the hair cycle shortens leading to baldness.
Rogaine is a popular brand associated with the drug minoxidil, but it’s not the only brand available.
In fact, there are many store brand minoxidil products available on the market and the majority work just as effectively as Rogaine.
That doesn’t mean that Rogaine will work for you and, in fact, we recommend you take more holistic approach to treating your hair loss.
To learn more about about the hair loss causes, prevention, and suitable solutions SCHEDULE A HAIR LOSS / RESTORATION CONSULTATION with one of our Trichologist.
Health & Beauty Tips
At PLEIJ Salon+Spa, we are committed to sharing health and beauty tips to enrich your life. Everyone deserves to live an empowered life and we want to help you get there.